Bug - Incoming spam emails is not sorted into junk folder

Blinkiz

@AnotherAndy Am sorry if I was not clear enough. My bad. As you can see in my first post, “X-Spam-Status” does not exist in the incoming email but “X-Spam” does.

jengelh

Dec 04 12:26:23 kopano kopano-dagent[4696]: Mail will be delivered in Inbox

Unless you define some rules, or have some other magical extra component that does it for you, it won’t be moved to Junk.

Blinkiz

@jengelh Hello there. Thanks for replying.
In the config file /etc/kopano/dagent.cfg it says

# The following e-mail header will mark the mail as spam, so the mail
# is placed in the Junk Mail folder, and not the Inbox.
# The name is case insensitive.
# set to empty to not use this detection scheme.
spam_header_name = X-Spam

I read it as the incoming email will be placed in the Junk Mail folder, and not the inbox. Is that not correct?

AnotherAndy

Hi @Blinkiz ,
that’s what I tried to say, use
“spam_header_name = X-Spam-Status” - without “” in your dagent.cfg
We had a similar topic here:
https://forum.kopano.io/topic/125/spam-is-not-sorted-into-junk-folder/4

Blinkiz

@AnotherAndy
Okay, I changed back to spam_header_name = X-Spam-Status and it still does not work. Again, I do not have a X-Spam-Status header in my incoming emails. I have X-Spam instead.

AnotherAndy

I’m sorry I thought you were also using spamassassin.
maybe @jengelh can tell the magic tricks to do

Blinkiz

I found why it does not work for me. Look at the incoming message I wrote in my first post.

root@kopano:[~]: grep -i 'spam' /tmp/raw_messages/LMTP_20181204122623_641be4e6.eml
X-Rspamd-Queue-Id: D428A44FF9
X-Spamd-Result: default: False [11.15 / 15.00];
X-Rspamd-Server: smtp
X-Spam: Yes

I then specify to look for X-Spam in my configuration.

root@kopano:[~]: cat /etc/kopano/dagent.cfg | egrep -v "(^#.*|^$)"
log_level	=	5
log_raw_message = yes
log_raw_message_path = /tmp/raw_messages
spam_header_name = X-Spam
spam_header_value = Yes

Looking at the source code at https://github.com/Kopano-dev/kopano-core/blob/master/spooler/DAgent.cpp i can see that only the first match is returned. In my Message I first have “X-Spamd-Result” which will be the one Kopano is checking against and not “X-Spam” header.

This is a bug in the Kopano code.

fbartels

Hi @Blinkiz ,

thanks for your report. I have created https://jira.kopano.io/browse/KC-1392 to follow this up.

micro

I am suffering from the same bug because still running kopano 8.5.9.0 and an update is being planned. But my question is: can I patch my dagent quickly as shown here?

https://stash.kopano.io/projects/KC/repos/kopanocore/commits/2cc0820c6ba1e4698ff0bc4d3e00ff017d737b68

what do I need to do to patch my existing kopano-dagent with this bugfix? In my understanding it would me need to modify just the line 2114 in dagent.cpp and somehow compile/update it so I can get a patched kopano-dagent binary. Can anyone show me the correct command and steps therefore? I tried to search for a “dagent.cpp” but no hits on my filesystem.

any help appreciated

jengelh

The patch (2cc082) is only in 8.7 and later which, incidentally, made its debut 365 days ago.

micro

hehe, nice pic :) does that mean I cannot just change this particular line to get/compile a new kopano-dagent ? are there other/many stuff affected for that patch being able to be effective?

bhuisman

@micro You are running a version that was released more than 1.5 years ago. I can’t tell if ‘just patching’ will lead to trouble - I would recommend that you upgrade to the latest version instead and benefit from all the other improvements and fixes.

micro

definitely you’re right. Nevertheless I am curious if this could be a “faster” workaround. It does not mean I will not upgrade, but the upgrade is more time intensive and currently time is very limited along other projects (higher importance). That was just a thought if I could workaround by this.

however, thanks for your reply.

Blinkiz

@micro Hello.
To fix his problem without upgrading, change incoming spam header into “X-Spam-Status” or something else that can not match multiple times in your email header. In my case I configure this in rspamd.

micro

that’s exactly what I intented to do when this solution mentioned here not possible. Did you configure this in local.d/worker-proxy.inc ?

Blinkiz

@micro said in Bug - Incoming spam emails is not sorted into junk folder:

that’s exactly what I intented to do when this solution mentioned here not possible. Did you configure this in local.d/worker-proxy.inc ?

I do not remember, sorry. Am running latest version of Kopano now days.

micro

ok, solved. Works like a charm now …